Michael Bardin
Growth Product Manager at Applica
Leads product optimization at Applica, turning paywalls, onboarding, and subscription flows into controlled experiments for mobile products
LinkedInProduct growth
App store optimization
Boost discoverability and store conversion through ongoing testing
Performance marketing
ROI-driven acquisition systems across all major ad platforms
Creatives production
Data-led creatives built and iterated for performance
Mobile user acquisition agency
Paid UA on Meta, Apple Ads, Google and TikTok, scaled on payback
App marketing agency
UA, ASO, creatives and paywall tests in one growth system
A single Black Friday discount shown to every user gives money away to people who would have paid full price anyway. Applica’s Michael Bardin joins Katya Madonova of Web2Wave to break down how to plan BFCM for subscription apps: segmenting by subscription life stage, triggering offers inside and outside the app, designing discounts by segment, and testing and measuring before the sale window opens.
Growth Product Manager at Applica
Leads product optimization at Applica, turning paywalls, onboarding, and subscription flows into controlled experiments for mobile products
LinkedIn
Product Marketing Lead at Web2Wave
Katya is a product marketing lead with 10+ years of professional experience, including 8+ years in the mobile app industry. She owns positioning, go-to-market, messaging, and lifecycle for B2B SaaS products that mobile teams actually use, end to end, from strategy to execution.
Black Friday looks like the easiest campaign of the year: pick a discount, put it on the paywall, show it to everyone. The numbers say otherwise. As Michael Bardin (Growth Product Manager at Applica) shared opening the session, last year total market revenue in Black Friday week was barely 0.3% higher than in October weeks – and many apps earned less, with lower conversion rates than in October.
The main reason: much of the discount goes to new installs who would have paid full price anyway. The second: every user across the monetization lifecycle gets treated the same. In this webinar, hosted by Katya Madonova (Product Marketing Lead at Web2Wave), Michael walked through the approach Applica uses with clients to plan BFCM for subscription apps – who sees an offer, when they see it, and what that offer is.
Applica splits users into four segments by their stage in the monetization lifecycle:
Fresh installs
People who have never used your app, coming from a Black Friday ad or organically from the store page
Freemium users
Active users who have seen your paywall but never paid
Lapsed subscribers
People who subscribed and then canceled
Current subscribers
Active subscribers who can be upsold during the sale
For each segment, the team makes three decisions: the trigger (how to reach the user – paywalls, banners, modals, push, email), the offer (plan, price, discount, intro or promo offer, web or in-app), and the framing (how the offer is presented). Michael's surprise from client work: the framing often matters as much as the discount itself.
For most B2C apps, the onboarding paywall drives 80%+ of revenue, so that's where the Black Friday offer goes. Sell the most expensive plan – the annual plan on the highest tier – with a discount that usually sits around 40-60%, depending on your normal price. If your onboarding paywall has a trial, keep it and attach the discount to that plan.
The framing lesson came from testing: hero Black Friday images with a big "60% off" didn't perform well. What worked best was leading with the product and keeping Black Friday secondary – as on a paywall Applica built for Dogo, where the main value proposition stays at the top and the sale is a badge. Another strong option is gift framing, such as selling 12 months as "1 + 11 months."
The abandoned paywall – shown when a user closes the onboarding paywall – follows different rules. Willingness to pay is lower, so the discount can be bigger, there's no trial, and an intro offer discounts only the first year. Urgency works here: timers and heavy discounts. Katya added one caution from her own experience: if your Meta campaigns are optimized for trials, talk to the product team before removing the trial.
Freemium users have seen your paywall and actively closed it. Reach them in-app first – banners and modals – then with push and email. A banner on your most-used tab should stay up for the whole campaign.
The key insight: these users have trained themselves to close paywalls automatically, so don't open with one. Set context first. Gift framing ("here's your gift – tap to open") converted best in Applica's work, and variable-reward mechanics like spin-the-wheel or shake-your-phone work too. As Katya noted, the same mechanics – scratch cards, spin-the-wheel – can be used on web paywalls.
On push: more than 80% of push-driven conversions came from either the first or the last notification, so the team now sends just two and avoids spamming users in between.
The best routes back are email or push leading to a web paywall – where a bigger discount is possible – plus store win-back offers and a "welcome back" flow that reminds users what the product feels like before showing an offer.
The most surprising result: for lapsed subscribers, price barely mattered. A $1 intro offer for a full year converted about as well as $20–30. If someone chose to stop paying, it usually wasn't about price, so framing does the heavy lifting.
The goal is moving users to a higher-LTV plan – monthly to annual, or a cheaper tier to a pricier one. Show the user's current plan, make clear the new plan starts only when the current period ends, and frame it around savings (or value plus savings for a tier upgrade). The discount typically applies to the first year only.
For most apps, fresh installs and freemium users drive roughly 70-80% of the impact. If you're a large product with plenty of current and lapsed subscribers, it's worth working across all four.
October is for preparation
Build all four segments in analytics and get every paywall, banner, modal, and push ready.
The campaign usually starts one to two weeks before Black Friday
This year, that likely means starting Thursday, November 19, through Black Friday on November 27, with final pushes, emails, and in-app modals in the last days and Cyber Monday on November 30.
Test only what you can read fast
Results transfer poorly from one year to the next, so don't test risky assumptions during the sale. If traffic allows, test on fresh installs: the offer on the onboarding vs. abandoned paywall, showing a monthly plan next to the annual plan to make it feel less expensive, and aggressive vs. gentle framing.
Measure against an October baseline
Most apps can't afford proper A/B tests during BFCM, so record weekly revenue per user per segment in October and compare each segment against it. That's how you see which segments the campaign actually worked for.
Black Friday isn't a discount – it's four campaigns running at once. Segment by lifecycle stage, pick the right trigger, offer, and framing for each, and measure per segment against a clean baseline. Watch the full session for the real paywall examples, the segment grid, and the Q&A on whether web funnels should advertise the sale before the paywall.
Thank you for subscription
to Applica Digest!
The latest mobile growth insights will be
delivered straight to your inbox